blue and white ironing board cover_black washing machine cover

Another entry on my list that you might not be expecting is liquid hot sauce because, again, the texture is different. But when it comes to heat and color, any liquid hot sauce is a good substitute for paprika.

Paprika

Yes, it will change the overall texture and appearance of your final dish or sauce. But, when it comes to heat and flavor profile, red pepper flakes are the closest to Hungarian or spicy paprika.